No name

The Prince of Egypt

Book cover: 'The Prince of Egypt'
Copyright: 
1999
Publisher: 
Dreamworks
Subject(s): 
Grade / Age level: 
Review: 
Three Other Reasons to See Prince of Egypt: racially truthful, stealthily pro-life, realistic portrayal of sin
I admit, our family went to see The Prince of Egypt because of William Donahoe's recommendation. The Catholic League plugged the newly-released animated picture on the story of Moses in its newsletter as well as in an Internet message. So we joined my family at Christmas in a rare trip to the theater, along with my dad (who was going to see it because Chuck Colson had recommended it).

When we emerged from the theater, all of us agreed that there was more reason to like this film than the facts that a.) it was completely clean b.) and it was not by Disney.

I had been told of the technical perfection of the animation and special effects. This is true - the film is stylistically executed by DreamWorks with the perfection of any Disney movie. The parting of the Red Sea is spectacular. It has its share of chases, escapes, and comic moments, with strong female characters and funny animals. The story is simple to follow - so clear that my toddler son burst into tears when baby Moses had to leave his mommy to be adopted by a strange lady. I had expected all these things.

But I wasn't expecting any more than an exercise in clean filming of a token Biblical story to please the Christian market. Prince was more than that. Here's three reasons to go see the film that have nothing to do with the political battle over children's movies.

First, Prince is racially truthful. This is the first Biblical movie I have seen in which none of the characters - none - were Caucasian. Personally I am tired of depictions of our Biblical fathers and mothers that insist on giving them fair skin and sometimes blue eyes. Both the Hebrews and the Egyptians in Prince have the bone structure and skin color of their races, which I found refreshingly (not politically) correct. Aren't the Jews and Africans sometimes right when they accuse American Christians of making the Gospel into "a white man's story?" Certainly these are the images we usually give our children. Prince was a definite step in the right direction.

The filmmaker's choice to tap the heritage of the black community in using a music style inspired by Gospel spirituals was wise and effective. For its audience of children, it provided a further link between the Biblical characters and the African heritage. The Hebrew songs - particularly the children's hymn which heralds the day of Israel's freedom - were wonderful touches. My personal favorite was "Through Heaven's Eyes," the song of Jethro, Moses' future father-in-law, done in Arabian style.

Second, there was the undercurrent of a pro-life message. The catalyst of Moses' transformation from a selfish prince of Egypt who never looks twice at his servants to the deliverer of Israel is when he discovers that his "father," the Pharaoh, commanded the slaughter of the infant Hebrew boys. His father justifies this as population control: "the Hebrews were too numerous." Moses, who can't imagine being related to slaves, begins to feel compassion first for these countless baby victims, whom he narrowly escaped joining. A sense of the enormity of the crime is overwhelming in different parts of the film. While not explicit, a pro-life message comes through. The last line of the film "Deliver us!" became for me a personal prayer for an end to our nation's holocaust.

Third, the movie shows clearly the effects of the most deadly of sins - pride. This film underscores the fact that the bulk of the plagues upon Egypt were the result of one man's selfishness and unwillingness to change - the Pharaoh Rameses. What makes this moral tale so believable is that the film explores the character of the hard-hearted Pharaoh in his boyhood friendship with Moses. "Don't be the weak link in the chain," Rameses' father tells him, unfairly punishing him for things he didn't do. The fact that Moses truly loves his foster brother and has compassion for his internal struggle even as the two face off as adults raises the caliber of the storyline. Moses begs Pharaoh to yield for the sake of the Egyptians suffering from the plagues, but Rameses, tormented by the sores and pests of the plagues himself, remains bitter and unyielding. He has lost the ability to feel compassion for anyone else. When he announces that the slaughter of Hebrew children will begin again, he brings down the plague of the death of the first-born upon himself. Faced with unwittingly causing the death of his young son, he temporarily agrees to let the Hebrews go. The stark portrayal of the effects of mortal sin has probably never been rendered to this depth in cartoon form before.

Having seen the movie, I would nominate it for an Academy Award. And along with William Donahoe and other Christian leaders, I can now say that I certainly hope that the movie industry makes more movies like Prince of Egypt (how about a sequel?). If you go to see Prince of Egypt, you'll "send a message to Hollywood," but you and your family will enjoy yourself as well.

Additional notes: 

Rated PG, 99 minutes

Executive Producer: Jeffrey Katzenberg

Director: Brenda Chapman, Steve Hickner and Simon Wells

Featuring the voice talents of: Val Kilmer, Ralph Fiennes, Sandra Bullock and Michelle Pfeiffer

Regina Doman is the author of The Shadow of the Bear: Snow White and Rose Red Retold, reviewed on this site and the mother of five children. She writes from Front Royal, VA.

Reviewed by: 
First reviewed: 
1998-99

The Princess and Curdie

Author(s): 
George MacDonald
Subject(s): 
Grade / Age level: 
Review: 
The Princess and Curdie continues the fantasy saga begun in MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin. This novel gets off to a slower start than the first one in the series, but it is just as attention-holding. Curdie, the young hero, is put to the test in this story, and must prove himself both brave and loyal, whilst remaining trustworthy and honest. In this story, Curdie is given the gifts of a magic of his own that can only be used for others and a faithful but unusual traveling companion. His quest takes him to the home of the Princess and provides a grand adventure, with the final suspenseful battle calling him to give his best.

This novel takes place just a short time after the events in the previous book and is best enjoyed by reading the first tale first. This classic work is also written on many different levels, and numerous allegorical references to Christianity are present. The ending is expected yet surprising and leaves the reader wanting more. We read this book in an inexpensive paperback edition, and we found the "word pictures" wonderful for stirring the imagination. I have been on the lookout for an illustrated edition to compare the artist's ideas with my own. The children also adored this story, although my 9 and 12-year-olds liked it best.

Reviewed by: 
First reviewed: 
4/19/01

The Princess and the Goblin

Author(s): 
George MacDonald
Subject(s): 
Grade / Age level: 
Review: 
The Princess and the Goblin is a classic fantasy novel written in the late 1800s by George MacDonald. The story features all of the elements of a great fairy tale: a young princess, a brave hero on the verge of adulthood, subtle magic, and more goblins than can be counted. There is enough adventure to keep the story moving, but the plot is not overwhelming or difficult to follow. There is nothing to recommend a caution for: no rough language, no adult situations, and very little violence. The violent scenes were in the context of the battles between good and evil and avoided gory descriptions. We read this novel in a beautifully illustrated edition; it is worth looking for one that has the lovely full-color plates.

But more than that, the story is written on several levels and can be enjoyed by many different age groups. After reading The Mysteries of Life in Children's Literature, I was anxious to begin reading this book aloud to my children. I had hesitated, thinking that my mainly-male audience would protest a "fairy tale". Their reaction surprised me! All of the children looked forward to the next chapter of the book, although the 9- and 12-year-olds enjoyed it the most.

Reviewed by: 
First reviewed: 
4/19/01

The Princess and the Kiss

Book cover: 'The Princess and the Kiss'
Author(s): 
Jennie Bishop
Number of pages: 
32 pages
Copyright: 
2000
Publisher: 
Warner Press
Binding: 
Sewn Hardcover
Grade / Age level: 
Resource Type: 
Review: 
"Long ago, in a wonderful castle on a mountain of splendor, a beautiful princess was born." So begins the story of The Princess and the Kiss, a tale of a young woman's - in this case princess's - first kiss. On the day she is born, her parents present her with this special gift from God. In a secret room in a castle tower, it is kept safely hidden away under glass. When she is old enough, her parents explain the treasured value of this precious gift and warn her to not give it to just anybody. Heeding their wise advice, she is not one to be bamboozled by the many interesting suitors who vie for her hand, from Prince Peacock to Prince Romance to Prince Treasurechest. She wonders if there ever will be a young man special enough for her to give her first kiss. At last, she meets a young man who impresses her with the purity of his heart.

In this day and age of sexual amorality, the ideal of purity and saving one's first kiss for another pure heart is refreshingly beautiful, especially since both of them have saved their first kiss for each other. For my four-year-old and seven-year-old daughters, this is one of their favorite stories, quite worn out already.

Additional notes: 

originally appeared in Heart and Mind Magazine, Summer 2005 - used with permission

Reviewed by: 
First reviewed: 
1998-99

The Queen's Thief Series (The Thief, The Queen of Attolia, The King of Attolia, A Conspiracy of Kings)

Author(s): 
Megan Whalen Turner
Grade / Age level: 
Review: 
If you, like us, have voracious readers always eager for, sometimes demanding, new reading material, Margaret Whalen Turner’s Queen’s Thief series is definitely worth a try. Set in a fictionalized version of Greece in something like the sixteenth century, the series continually reveals Mrs. Turner’s love for Greece, its landscape, mythology, learning and even politics. The stories are set in three small adjoining countries, Sounis, Eddis and Attolia. Political relationships among these three kingdoms drive the macro-plots, with their internal struggles influenced by the encroachments of the powerful Medean Empire. The central characters present a wide variety of personality, each heavily formed by the political role they must play as leaders of their nations. The ambitious, not terribly clever but committed King of Sounis; his diplomatic advisor, the learned Magus, trying to serve his King while looking to the broader interest of an anti-Mede peace in the region; the down-to-earth, good-hearted, understanding Queen of Eddis who rules through her barons’ love and loyalty; the cold, beautiful Queen of Attolia, driven to ruthlessness by the need to assert her rule over barons who would use or destroy her. Mrs. Turner effortlessly develops what could be merely stock characters into unique individuals, rich, interesting, believable. Her masterpiece is Eugenides. His office is an ingenious creation of Mrs. Turner’s – the Queen’s Thief. Part spy, part saboteur, yet a hereditary office of nobility and no creation of the state ruler, its powers and responsibilities mold Eugenides’ character. In many ways immature, or liking the freedom of playing the immature role, Eugenides enjoys pulling the wool over everyone’s eyes, which his intelligence and wit allow him to do. Yet his commitment to his office and his queen leads him to greater and greater sacrifice as the stories unfold. Eugenides’ pain, more prominent in the second and third books than in the first, is intense and convincing. He grows into maturity through difficult choices and sufferings until, in the most recent installment, he becomes a model and guide for a young friend thrust into a kingship he did not want. Tremendously important to Eugenides’ development are the gods. Like other aspects of her stories, Mrs. Turner’s presentation of the gods reminds me in some ways of CS Lewis’s Till We Have Faces. First introduced through myths shared around the campfire by the Magus and Eugenides, the gods become real participants through their providential interaction with and on behalf of Eugenides. Mrs. Turner’s gods are providential yet not comforting, demanding not by commanding but by their stern, austere, simple superiority. Eugenides encounters the gods not as a child or a favorite. He is someone from a different world, out of step, unsure of what is expected or how he is to relate to them. I think of Oedipus at Colonus when I read Mrs. Turner’s account of her presentation:
What I wanted to create was a pantheon that might have inspired in my characters the same feelings that the ancient Greeks had for their gods....or would have had if a civilization like theirs had developed for another thousand years without the rise of monotheism.
Eugenides cannot manipulate the gods, or fool them, or cajole them. He simply has to obey them--not because of threats or rewards, but because they simply belong to another plane of being that must be obeyed. Nor is it that he doesn’t revolt, or at least drag his feet. His relationship with them is fascinating, and at times ruefully funny in a way that many Catholics can understand. In The King of Attolia, Eugenides gripes about the way they treat his many sacrifices:
"No 'Glory will be your reward for me’. Oh no, for me, it is, 'Stop Whining' and 'Go To Bed' …I should know better. Never call on them, Costis, if you don’t really want them to appear.”
Amazon considers the books appropriate for the 9-12 age group. This seems to indicate the vocabulary level, and perhaps reflects the light-heartedness of much of the first book in the series, The Thief, narrated by Eugenides himself. But the wit and fun of that book will certainly entertain older children, and themes, plots and characters of the rest of the series are satisfying to adults as well. Like Eugenides, Mrs. Turner likes to keep a light, self-deprecating tone in her storytelling and yet knows how to intensify the writing as appropriate. The series has become favorite read-aloud material for our family, who keep me going much past what I know should be the time to stop. Mrs. Turner excels at leaving little clues about the deeper layers of the plot in such a way that continually surprises us at its unmasking, and rewards our re-reading with a delightful sense of “I get it now” and “How clever!” I accidentally discovered The Queen's Thief series through reading an application essay for Thomas Aquinas College. I am grateful to that student for introducing me and my family to an excellent reading experience.
Additional notes: 

Content warnings: Throughout the series, Eugenides and others periodically use milder swear words. Several scenes of sudden violence occur in different books, including a maiming. The King of Attolia contains implicit references to conjugal relationships.

Reviewed by Andrew Seeley, PhD

First reviewed: 
5-14-2010

The Quiet Light

A novel of St. Thomas Aquinas
Book cover: 'The Quiet Light: A novel of St. Thomas Aquinas'
Author(s): 
Louis de Wohl
Copyright: 
1950
Publisher: 
Ignatius Press
Binding: 
Sewn Softcover
Setting: 
Grade / Age level: 
Review: 
Disclaimer: best suited for high schoolers due to an incident where Thomas Aquinas is tempted by his brothers when they bring a prostitute to his room one night. Also, there are a few quick references to 'wenches' .

The dust jacket reads that the "theme of this novel was suggested to Louis de Wohl, in a private audience, by His Holiness, Pope Pius XII in 1948". The Quiet Light was printed two years later.

The book tells the story of the life of Thomas Aquinas from the eyes of his family members. It is a well-written novel, with an exciting plot and a complement of well-rounded characters. We see Thomas Aquinas as a shy, and supposedly dull-witted, schoolboy who earns himself the name of "The Dumb Ox". It isn't until college that his legendary genius is revealed. We learn how Thomas's wealthy family are terribly opposed to his decision to become a Dominican, and of their many attempts to thwart his personal plan. The author makes Saint Thomas Aquinas come alive, and we are left with a deep impression of the impact that this saint made in his time.

The novel is also noteworthy for its historical content. It is a wonderful case study of life in the thirteenth century in Europe. We learn of feuding barons, fleeing popes, politically-motivated marriages, chivalry, feasting, the crusades, and life in a monastary.

Most importantly, this is a Catholic novel. We are touched by the depth of the faith of St. Thomas Aquinas, and awe-struck by the miracles that occur later in his life.

For highschoolers studying the Middle Ages, or anyone who wants to learn more about this important saint, The Quiet Light is highly recommended.

Perspective: 
Catholic
Reviewed by: 
First reviewed: 
1998-99

The Railway Children

Book cover: 'The Railway Children'
Author(s): 
Edith Nesbit
Number of pages: 
288 pages
Copyright: 
1906
Publisher: 
Puffin Books
Binding: 
Softcover
Subject(s): 
Grade / Age level: 
Review: 
Rebecca, Peter and Phyllis are three British children (around the turn of the century) who live in a large, beautiful house in London with their lovely and creative mother and their very attentive father. One night their lives change dramatically when their father is mysteriously called away. The children and their mother have to "play at being poor" for awhile, pack up only what seems necessary and move to a house out in the country near a railway station. The story tells of their adventures in and around the railway station and the gradually unfolding mystery regarding their father. It's a lovely family story and Mrs. Nesbit is quite a gifted and interesting author. In the midst of their adventures, we discover a lot about character and the devotion children should have for their parents. This story is a great read-aloud for the whole family, and can be read independely by mid-grade-schoolers on up.

Reviewed by: 
First reviewed: 
4-7-2000

The Reb and the Redcoats

Book cover: The Reb and the Redcoats
Author(s): 
Constance Savery
Number of pages: 
203 pages
Copyright: 
1961
ISBN: 
9781883937423
Publisher: 
Bethlehem Books
Binding: 
Softcover
Subject(s): 
Grade / Age level: 
Review: 

The Reb and the Redcoats is an adventurous historical fiction story about a British family during the American Revolution who "play host" to an American prisoner of war. 15 year old Randal is a well-educated Virginian who was sent on a military mission as a French interpreter. When he and his comrades are captured, he gives his captors no end of trouble with his escape attempts and is finally confined to an old penance cell at the estate of Laurence Templeton (which had once been a monastery). Things get interesting when Captain Templeton's elder sister, Mrs. Darrington and her four children arrive for an indefinite stay at the estate. The children are fascinated by the American Rebel and can't understand why Uncle Laurence is so resentful of his presence.

This is one of the most delightful stories I've read in a long time. Although it is recommended for ages 10 and up, our entire family enjoyed this story immensely. Not only is it a very enjoyable and well-told tale (with accurate historical details), but there are some very nice lessons tied into the story about how we should treat other people and how easy it is to misjudge.

Reviewed by: 
First reviewed: 
1998-99

The Reb and the Redcoats

Book cover: 'The Reb and the Redcoats'
Author(s): 
Constance Savery
Number of pages: 
203 pages
Copyright: 
1961
Publisher: 
Bethlehem Books
Binding: 
Softcover
Subject(s): 
Grade / Age level: 
Review: 
One of the many books my wife discovered. After she read it aloud to the kids they wanted me to read it to them AGAIN at their nightly story time before bed. Though this novel is written for children I stayed up late to finish it myself after one such session! It takes place in England during the American Revolutionary War. The main character of the book is a captured American 'Rebel'. He is befriended by the children of the country house where he is held prisoner. But by his actions he proves so honorable that he is given freedom to roam the estate and is eventually even hired, during his captivity, to tutor the children in their studies. Everyone in the family begins to love him - but he is bound to escape and complete his mission. I will let YOU stay up late to find out what happens.

I found this book full of living examples of the many virtues that make up an honorable person (honesty, loyalty, integrity, desire to learn, courtesy, etc.) and yet also just plain enjoyable. The style includes glimpses into human nature that make you laugh when you unexpectedly recognize them.

Reviewed by: 
First reviewed: 
1998-99

Pages